Cognitive Consistency and Environmental Action

Heberlein, T. A., & Black, J. S. (1981). Cognitive consistency and environmental action. Environment and Behavior, 13, 6, 717-734.

A study of 330 gasoline purchasers revealed that cognitive consistency applies to environmental attitudes and behavior. Most Ss who were observed to engage in proenvironmental behavior (purchasing lead-free gasoline) had 2 consistent cognitions--a belief that their behavior was economically expedient and a feeling of personal obligation. Those who held both beliefs and behaved consistently reported greater social support and more supporting beliefs than those who manifested cognitive inconsistency. They also showed a greater behavioral commitment to purchasing lead-free. Data suggest that cognitions are organized as opinion molecules and that behavior is consistent with attitudes. (25 ref)

Or: Abstract #2: Cognitive consistency applies to environmental attitudes & behavior, as is demonstrated by data gathered from the questionnaire responses of 266 gas station dealers & 330 purchasers of lead-free gasoline in Wisc. Most individuals who engaged in a proenvironmental behavior (purchasing lead-free gasoline) had two consistent cognitions-a belief that their behavior was economically expedient & a feeling of personal obligation. Those who held both beliefs & behaved consistently reported greater social support & more supporting beliefs than those who manifested cognitive inconsistency. They also showed a greater behavioral commitment to purchasing lead-free. These data suggest that cognitions are organized as opinion molecules & that behavior is consistent with attitudes. This attitude-behavior consistency is more likely to be observed when behavioral choice is unconstrained, as it was when the data were collected in 1973, before government regulations limited consumer choices.
3 Tables. Modified HA

Find this article online
New 4TH Edition

Available Today!

Fostering Sustainable Behavior Book Cover

The latest edition of Fostering Sustainable Behavior features updated research, case studies, and practical strategies that can substantially impact the adoption of sustainable behaviors.

Site Courtesy of
McKenzie-Mohr & Associates

Expertise in Community-Based Social Marketing